°

Homepage / Health
Text Size

Gaining Weight? Maybe It's Just Water

Water Weight Causes Fluctuations

POSTED: Friday, February 23, 2007

Have you ever popped onto the scale only to see that your weight has shot up 5 pounds since the last time you weighed?

Blame water.
Exercise Myths | Exercise At Work | Health Journals

"Most (day-to-day) fluctuation is fluid retention," said Dr. Jason Cisler, of Omaha's Gastro-Intestinal Associates.

No one is more frustrated by this phenomenon than a dieter.

"Water retention is sneaky," said Tori, who lives in Alexandria, Va., and asked that we not use her last name. She recently lost 40 pounds.

"I can eat well, employ proper nutrition, but step on the scale and be up a pound or two," she said.

Drinking May Not Add Water

But why are you holding onto water? The answer is likely both sides of the same coin -- you're either getting too much water or too little.

Most Americans are in the latter camp, getting too little noncaffeinated liquid in their daily diets.

"Are you always just drinking pop?" asked Judy Held, a registered dietitian at St. Luke's Regional Medical Center in Sioux City, Iowa. "A lot of people don't get in a lot of water. They think because they're drinking coffee or pop (they're covered)."

But caffeine in those drinks pushes water out of cells, Held said, so they are really a wash when it comes to how much fluid is available for the body.

In fact, a study by Children's Hospital and Research Center found that sipping more water helped research participants lose more weight than people who drank low- or no-calorie drinks such tea and soda.

Diet, Weather Affect Water In Body

Sudden weight gains may also be a result of sodium or humidity, which can make people retain fluid. For women, hormones can make their bodies retain in the week around their menstrual cycle.

A chronic or temporary digestive problem could also put pounds on for a time.

Tour Your Digestive Tract

Generally, liquids move through your system quickly -- no surprise to anyone checking out for a bathroom break shortly after downing their morning latte. Food moves through the digestive tract at different speeds, depending on how dense it is and what nutrients it contains.

Cisler offered a timeline of how food moves through the body for a healthy person:

  • Mouth to stomach: The transit down the esophagus takes seconds.
  • Stomach: Primarily a storage unit, the stomach only begins to break food up using chemicals and muscle. Over about two or three hours, the stomach will release food into the small intestine, but only as fast as that organ can process it.
  • Small intestine: This 20-foot organ does most of the digesting, and that can take up to six hours. This is where cells pick up nutrients and the body gets fueled. It may also be where a doctor would go looking for an obstruction if your weight gain were sudden and significant.
  • Large intestine/colon: The main function here is to absorb water. It reduces the volume by 15 times. This process should take a day and a half, regardless of what you've eaten.
  • So, no matter how badly you feel about eating that super-sized value meal, you're not getting rid of it for a couple of days.

    Bloat Can Mean Problems

    If you're having a hard time linking your recent dietary habits to the weight gain, or if you notice swelling in the extremities, your bloat may signal a medical problem and you should see a doctor.

    Cisler said the possibilities include irritable bowl syndrome, a blockage, thyroid disease or lactose intolerance.

    It may also be that you're not getting enough fiber, or that you're not drinking enough water to allow the fiber to work.

    Insoluble fiber, found in abundance in vegetables, acts like a broom in the body by absorbing water and pushing waste through the digestive tract, according to the American Dietetic Association's Complete Food and Nutrition Guide.

    "By moving waste through the colon, insoluble fibers increase the rate at which wastes are removed," author Roberta Larson Duyff writes.

    "Whenever you increase your fiber content, you better be increasing your fluid content, too, or you're to have the opposite effect," Held said.

    Some people may react to the sweetener sorbitol, which is in a lot of sugarless products. Small amounts can contribute to swelling in your belly.

    "Sorbitol pulls water into your large intestine, which can cause bloating and, in high enough doses, diarrhea," said Dr. Michael Cox, a gastroenterologist at Mercy Medical Center in Baltimore, told Shape Magazine. "One study published in the journal 'Gastroenterology' found that just 10 grams of sorbitol (the equivalent of a few sugar-free candies) produced symptoms."

    Fight-Back Tactics

    You can push the scale back down by using a few strategies.

    First, weigh correctly. You wouldn't expect an accurate reading if you stood on the scale holding your lunch in a paper bag, so don't expect an accurate reading if your lunch has already been eaten.

    "An average-sized meal can easily weigh a couple of pounds," according to CalorieKing.com. "The scale registers the weight of the food, not the weight you will have gained from the meal."

    The same goes for what time you weigh. Dietitians recommend weighing each morning in the nude after emptying your bladder. Cisler suggested weighing just once a week, and under the same circumstances on the same scale, since different devices can give slightly different readings.

    Aim for a "no-salt-added" diet, Held said. That means you never pick up a saltshaker. U.S. dietary guidelines from the Department of Agriculture suggest 2,300 milligrams a day -- or about 1 teaspoon of table salt.

    High-sodium diets can make your kidneys work overtime to get rid of if, Duyff writes, and your body can fight to hang onto the water by retaining it. That can lead to swelling.

    And don't forget, muscle weighs more than fat, so if you're hitting the gym hard, you may see the scale rise by a few pounds. To see if you should reward yourself for the gain, Held suggests using a tape measure to note body composition. That should make it easier to see that the scale isn't the only tool for tracking a healthy lifestyle.

    Finally, the body needs time to process nutrition, so give yourself a break and allow the scale to float within a few pounds. If a couple of pounds start to stick around, you may need to reassess your diet and exercise routine. Blog Post:

  • Water To Lose Weight?
  • Other Links:

  • Find A Virtual Personal Trainer
  • Low-Cost Exercise
  • Secrets Of The Weight-Loss Industry
  • Find The Perfect Gym
  • The views expressed are not those of JustNews.com, WPLG or its affiliated companies. This is a community moderated forum. (Please note the 'Like' and 'Report' tabs.) By posting your comments you agree to accept our Terms of Use.

    Comments

    blog comments powered by Disqus

    Links We Like

    Sponsored Content
    Symptoms of bipolar disorder may vary from person to person. Learn how to spot periods of mania and depression. More

    Before you splurge on that pricey remodeling project, beware. It may not pay you back when it's time to sell. More

    If you have aspirations of becoming a millionaire, check out these five habits that may be worth emulating. More

    If it seems like you’re always overpaying for car insurance, find out what you can do to keep those costs down. More

    Most Popular


    Marketplace

    • AutoClick to Expand

      • Tips From A Police Officer

        There are a few simple rules to follow when pulled over. It doesn't have to be any more unpleasant than it already is -- considering that it's likely you will come away with a fat ticket.

      • Why Do All Cars Look the Same?

        Have you ever exited a supermarket and wondered why you couldn't find your car? Chances are you suffered from something all of us have at some point: cars tend to look a lot alike these days. But, why?

      • Why Does Gas Cost So Much?

        It's a valid question, especially when gas prices fluctuate overnight for no apparent reason. A reasonable person has a right to wonder what's going on.

      • Our Top 5 Favorite Road Trip Games Of All Time

        Road trip games, those boredom-battling tests of concentration and quick vision meant to speed the hours. We thought we'd take a look at five in-car games that have been handed down since the dawn of the car itself.

      • Cheap Car Drives Like A Pricey One

        The Volkswagen Jetta is the best deal in town if you like the idea of a solid sedan or wagon with European flair.

    • JobsClick to Expand

    • Mental HealthClick to Expand

      • Understand Depression

        Millions of people deal with depression each year. Learn the basics of the disorder and how you can get help.

      • Overcome Your Anxiety

        If your anxiety feels unmanageable, seek medical help to get the right diagnosis and treatment.

      • 10 Natural Ways To Beat The Blues

        Everyone goes through tough times. Start banishing your blues by following some of these suggestions.

    • InsuranceClick to Expand

      • Auto Insurance Quotes

        Simply enter your zip code and get great deals on your car insurance from the top companies. Click here and start saving today!

      • Health Insurance Quotes

        No matter where you live, you shouldn’t have to pay too much for health insurance. Your zip code is all you need and we’ll do the rest to find you great insurance rates.

      • Home Insurance Quotes

        Your home is your most valuable asset. So make sure you have coverage that fits your needs and doesn’t break the bank.

      • Life Insurance Quotes

        What would happen to your family if you were suddenly gone? Don’t leave their future to chance and find top quality life insurance before it’s too late.

      • Business Insurance Quotes

        Don’t take chances when it comes to insuring your business. To get the best rates from top companies in your area just enter your zip code.

    • HomesClick to Expand

      • Top 10 Home Updates That Pay Off

        Wondering if you'll be able to recoup the cost of your next home remodeling project? It's tough to know in today's market.

      • Storage And Organization Guide

        Clutter makes a home look smaller and less valuable. Learn how to maximize your space with the top five storage and organization projects that can increase your home's value.

      • Top 10 Things To Know Before Buying Your First Home

        Want to avoid mistakes and make a smart purchase? Here's what you need to know.

      • Home Budget Updates

        Need to spruce up your house before you sell? These low-cost upgrades will boost your market value without breaking the bank.

      • Staging Tips That Sell

        There is a lot you can do to get your home ready that doesn't cost much money; it just takes time and hard work.

    Sponsored Links